The Texas Court of Appeals has ruled in a significant arbitration case involving Charles Herd, Brandon Francis, and their law firm, Herd Law Firm, PLLC, against Leslie Jones. The court's decision, issued on November 17, 2026, reverses a lower court's order that denied the law firm's motion to compel arbitration. This ruling is crucial as it clarifies the enforceability of arbitration agreements in attorney-client relationships, particularly in malpractice claims.

Leslie Jones engaged Herd Law Firm to represent her in a personal injury lawsuit. The legal representation was governed by an engagement agreement that included both an arbitration clause and a venue provision. The arbitration clause required that any disputes arising from the agreement be resolved through binding arbitration, while the venue provision specified that any lawsuits would be filed in Harris County, Texas. The case, docket number 14-25-00923-CV, highlights the complexities that can arise when arbitration agreements are combined with venue provisions.

The dispute began when Jones filed a lawsuit against Herd Law Firm and its attorneys for professional negligence. The law firm sought to compel arbitration, arguing that the agreement clearly outlined the process for resolving disputes. However, Jones opposed this motion, claiming that the venue provision contradicted the arbitration clause, suggesting that there was no mutual agreement to arbitrate. She also argued that the arbitration clause was unconscionable due to a lack of necessary disclosures made by the law firm.

The trial court initially sided with Jones, denying the motion to compel arbitration on October 7, 2025. This prompted the appeal to the Texas Court of Appeals, where the law firm argued that the trial court had made an error in its ruling.

The Texas Court of Appeals, presided over by Justice Chad Bridges, reviewed the case and determined that the venue provision and the arbitration clause could be reconciled. The court stated, "Because the venue provision and the arbitration clause are reconcilable, we reverse the trial court’s order denying the motion to compel arbitration." This ruling underscores the court's position that the presence of both clauses in the agreement does not negate the enforceability of the arbitration clause.

The court emphasized that the arbitration provision explicitly stated that arbitration proceedings would be conducted in Harris County, Texas, which aligned with the venue provision. The court noted that the venue clause did not exclude arbitration but rather governed court proceedings that might occur alongside arbitration, such as motions to compel or confirm arbitration awards.

Moreover, the court found that Jones's argument regarding unconscionability lacked sufficient evidence. The court pointed out that Jones had not demonstrated any factual basis for her claims of unconscionability, as she did not provide evidence to support her assertions about the arbitration clause being inadequately explained or negotiated. The court remarked that there is no legal requirement for attorneys to explain arbitration provisions in engagement agreements.

This ruling has significant implications for both clients and attorneys in Texas. It reinforces the validity of arbitration agreements in legal contracts, particularly in malpractice cases, and clarifies that such agreements can coexist with venue provisions. The court's decision is likely to encourage more law firms to include arbitration clauses in their engagement agreements, knowing that these provisions can be enforced even when a venue clause is present.

Looking ahead, the case has been remanded back to the trial court with instructions to compel arbitration and stay the proceedings until arbitration has occurred. This means that Jones will have to resolve her claims against Herd Law Firm through arbitration rather than in court. The ruling sets a precedent that may influence how similar cases are handled in the future, particularly regarding the enforceability of arbitration agreements in attorney-client relationships.

As for what’s next, it remains to be seen whether Jones will seek further appeals following the arbitration process. The court's decision does not preclude her from pursuing other legal avenues, but for now, the arbitration agreement will govern how her claims are addressed.