The Utah Court of Appeals recently upheld a juvenile court's decision regarding the custody of a minor, P.S., affirming that a permanent guardianship was in the child's best interest rather than terminating the parental rights of J.S. and H.S., the child's parents. This ruling, filed under Case No. 20251502-CA on November 19, 2026, highlights the complexities involved in child welfare cases, especially when parents show signs of recovery from past issues.
The case began when P.S. was removed from his parents' custody due to their history of substance abuse and domestic violence. Despite the parents' improvements in their personal lives, the State of Utah filed a petition to terminate their parental rights. The juvenile court, however, decided against termination, favoring a permanent guardianship that would allow the child to maintain a relationship with his parents.
Background
J.S. and H.S. began their relationship in 2019 and were married in 2020. Over the years, they faced numerous challenges, including a significant history of substance abuse and domestic violence. They had three children together, all of whom were adjudicated as abused and neglected, leading to the parents voluntarily relinquishing their parental rights to those children.
In August 2023, a domestic violence incident led to H.S.'s conviction for aggravated assault against J.S. Following this, J.S. entered a residential treatment program for substance abuse. However, she relapsed shortly after her release, prompting the State to file a petition alleging that P.S. had been abused and neglected. The parents later stipulated to these allegations.
After the stipulation, both parents made notable strides in their recovery. J.S. had been sober for six months and was employed, while H.S. had also shown progress, engaging in recovery activities and maintaining stable housing. Despite their improvements, the juvenile court determined that the parents had not fully remedied the circumstances that led to P.S.'s removal.
The Ruling
During a three-day bench trial in late 2025, the juvenile court evaluated the State's petition to terminate the parents' rights. The court acknowledged the parents' progress but emphasized their long histories of substance abuse and domestic violence. Ultimately, the court ruled that terminating the parents' rights was not in P.S.'s best interest.
The court stated, "It is not in [Child’s] best interest to return to either parent at that time," and concluded that a permanent guardianship would allow P.S. to maintain a relationship with his parents while ensuring his safety.
The court also considered two potential placements for P.S.: his relatives, who were unwilling to accept a permanent guardianship, and family friends who were prepared to take on that role. The court expressed a preference for the relatives but ultimately decided to give them an opportunity to reconsider their position.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for child welfare cases in Utah. It emphasizes the importance of considering a child's best interests while also recognizing the potential for parental recovery. The court's decision to favor a permanent guardianship over termination of parental rights reflects a growing understanding of the complexities involved in such cases.
The ruling may influence future cases where parents show signs of improvement but still face challenges. It highlights the court's discretion in determining the best course of action for the child, balancing the need for safety with the desire to maintain family connections.
What's Next
The State and the Guardian ad Litem have appealed the juvenile court's ruling, and the outcome of this appeal could further clarify the standards for determining parental rights in similar cases. The court's decision may also prompt discussions about the role of kinship placements in child welfare decisions, particularly when relatives express hesitance to engage in guardianship.
Read Next
Utah Court of Appeals upholds dismissal in home purchase case
Utah court rules on divorce property and custody issues
Utah Court upholds aggravated murder convictions in shooting
Nevada Court Denies Hollman, Inc.'s Petition for Writ
Court rules on family farm dispute involving easement request
Court affirms ruling in Starowitz family farm dispute










