The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals has dismissed an appeal from Sanjay Singh, one of the defendants in a civil enforcement action brought by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The court ruled that it lacked jurisdiction over the appeal because the order Singh sought to challenge was not final or otherwise appealable. This decision affects Singh and the ongoing litigation involving other defendants in the case.
The SEC initiated this action against Singh and three other defendants, including Royal Bengal Logistics, Inc. The case centers around allegations of securities law violations. Singh, representing himself, appealed a summary judgment order issued by the district court on May 21, 2026, which found him and another defendant liable but did not resolve the SEC's claims against the remaining defendant.
The dispute arose when the SEC filed its complaint in the Southern District of Florida, claiming that Singh and the other defendants engaged in fraudulent activities related to the sale of securities. The SEC sought various forms of relief, including monetary penalties and injunctions against future violations. Singh's appeal stemmed from the district court's summary judgment ruling, which he believed concluded the litigation regarding his liability.
In its ruling, the Eleventh Circuit explained that it lacked jurisdiction to hear Singh's appeal. The court pointed out that the May 21 order was not final for two primary reasons. First, it did not determine the relief the SEC was entitled to receive. The court referenced the precedent set in Liberty Mutual Ins. Co. v. Wetzel, stating that an action is not final if it resolves liability but leaves the relief request unresolved. Second, the court noted that the order did not dispose of all claims in the case, as the SEC's claims against Royal Bengal Logistics, Inc. remained unresolved. This aligns with the court's previous ruling in Supreme Fuels Trading FZE v. Sargeant, which established that an order disposing of fewer than all claims is not final.
Furthermore, the court determined that the order was not appealable under the collateral order doctrine, which allows for certain non-final orders to be appealed under specific circumstances. The court explained that the order was intertwined with the merits of the case, as it resolved the liability of two defendants. The court referenced Acheron Capital, Ltd. v. Mukamal, noting that for an order to be appealable under the collateral order doctrine, it must be separate from and collateral to the merits.
As a result of this ruling, the Eleventh Circuit dismissed Singh's appeal for lack of jurisdiction. The court also denied all pending motions as moot, meaning that they were no longer relevant due to the dismissal of the appeal.
This ruling has implications for Singh and the other defendants involved in the SEC's enforcement action. Since the appeal was dismissed, the case will continue in the district court, where the SEC's claims against Royal Bengal Logistics, Inc. and any potential relief for the SEC remain to be determined. The dismissal of the appeal does not prevent Singh from continuing to defend himself in the ongoing litigation.
Looking ahead, Singh may have the option to appeal any final judgment issued by the district court once the litigation concludes. However, as of now, the court's dismissal of his appeal means that he must await the outcome of the SEC's case against him and the other defendants before pursuing further legal action. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any related cases or additional defendants involved in the SEC's enforcement action.
Read Next
Court dismisses appeal of man sentenced for child enticement
Court affirms 48-month sentence for drug conspiracy role
Court affirms ruling in Frazetta copyright case against Vanguard
Ninth Circuit Reverses Driver Provider Ruling on Wage Claims
Louisiana Court Reverses Ruling in Oil Royalty Dispute
Court affirms Shreveport's approval of data center permit










