A New York court has dismissed a lawsuit against Coinbase, Inc., a major cryptocurrency exchange, in which users claimed that their Bitcoin and other digital assets were stolen from their accounts. The court ruled that the claims were time-barred and did not adequately meet the legal definitions for securities under federal law. This decision affects users who believed they had a valid claim against Coinbase for the alleged theft of their digital assets.
The ruling, made by Judge Andrew Borrok of the New York Supreme Court on November 13, 2026, is significant as it clarifies the legal standing of cryptocurrency transactions and the responsibilities of exchanges like Coinbase. The case, known as Garrett v. Coinbase, Inc. (Index No. 156455/2025), involved multiple plaintiffs, including Cynthia Garrett, Henry Gonzalez, Scott Chung, Curt Burns, David Cooper, and Craig Bernstein.
Background
The dispute arose when the plaintiffs alleged that unknown third parties had stolen their Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies from their Coinbase accounts. They filed the lawsuit, claiming that Coinbase had violated the Securities Act of 1933 by providing unregistered securities in the form of “internal ledger entries.” The plaintiffs sought a declaratory judgment, asserting that these entries constituted securities under the law, and argued that Coinbase failed to protect their assets.
This case reached the New York Supreme Court after the plaintiffs filed an amended complaint (AC) in response to Coinbase's initial motion to dismiss. Coinbase, represented by attorneys from Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP, argued that the claims were not only time-barred but also lacked legal merit. The plaintiffs were represented by MDF Law, PLLC, and Franco Law PLLC.
The Ruling
The court ruled in favor of Coinbase, stating that the amended complaint must be dismissed. Judge Borrok emphasized that the claims were time-barred under the statute of limitations, which requires that actions to enforce certain liabilities must be brought within one year of discovery or within three years of the security being offered to the public. The court noted that the plaintiffs' claims regarding internal ledger entries became time-barred as of 2015.
The court ruled, "the AC must be dismissed because the CPLR 3211(a)(1) documentary evidence contradicts the claim that the Plaintiffs did not acquire Bitcoin or cryptocurrency, and that they instead merely acquired 'internal account credits' and/or 'internal ledger entries' from Coinbase."
Furthermore, the court found that the plaintiffs did not adequately allege that the internal ledger entries were securities under the Howey test, which determines whether certain transactions qualify as investment contracts. The judge pointed out that the profits and losses from Bitcoin are tied to the market value of the cryptocurrency itself, rather than the efforts of Coinbase.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for cryptocurrency users and exchanges. It reinforces the idea that digital assets like Bitcoin are not classified as securities under the law, particularly when the exchange provides a platform for trading rather than an investment contract. The court's decision could deter similar lawsuits against cryptocurrency exchanges, as it sets a precedent regarding the legal interpretation of digital asset ownership and the responsibilities of exchanges.
For users, the ruling underscores the importance of understanding the terms of service and user agreements associated with cryptocurrency platforms. Coinbase's user agreement clearly states that ownership of digital assets remains with the user and not with Coinbase, which played a crucial role in the court's decision.
What's Next
The plaintiffs in this case may consider appealing the decision, but details about any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. There may also be related cases pending that could further clarify the legal landscape surrounding cryptocurrency and securities law.
Read Next
Court upholds conviction of Russell Smith for first-degree rape
Court affirms collective action certification in wage dispute
Court upholds negligence claims in construction accident case
Ninth Circuit Reverses Driver Provider Ruling on Wage Claims
Louisiana Court Reverses Ruling in Oil Royalty Dispute
Court affirms Shreveport's approval of data center permit









