In a recent ruling, the North Carolina Court of Appeals upheld the conviction of Jonathan Ponce Brayboy for discharging a weapon into an occupied moving vehicle and two counts of assault with a deadly weapon. The court ruled on November 18, 2026, that Brayboy’s defense of automatism, which claims a person acted without conscious control, was not warranted in this case. This decision affects Brayboy, who was found guilty in a lower court, and sets a precedent for similar cases regarding the automatism defense.
The case stems from an incident on October 28, 2020, when Brayboy was involved in a confrontation with Damian Ransom, who was visiting his ex-partner, Taylor Strickland. Ransom discovered Brayboy in a compromising position with Strickland, which led to a physical altercation. After the fight, as Ransom was leaving with his son, Brayboy allegedly fired shots at Ransom's vehicle, striking it multiple times. This led to Brayboy's arrest and subsequent trial.
During the trial, Brayboy claimed he had suffered a concussion from the earlier fight and could not recall the shooting. He argued that he should have been allowed to present an automatism defense, which would suggest he was not in control of his actions due to his mental state. However, the trial court did not instruct the jury on this defense, leading to Brayboy's appeal.
The Court of Appeals, led by Judge Jefferson Griffin, reviewed the trial court's decision. The court found that Brayboy had not preserved the automatism defense for appeal, as he did not request the jury instruction during the trial. The court stated, “The trial court did not err in instructing the jury,” and concluded that the evidence did not support Brayboy's claim that he acted without conscious control.
In its analysis, the court referenced previous cases regarding the automatism defense. The court noted that for such a defense to be applicable, there must be substantial evidence showing that the defendant was unconscious or unable to control their actions at the time of the offense. In Brayboy's case, the medical expert testified that while Brayboy had symptoms consistent with a concussion, there was no evidence that he was unconscious during the shooting. The expert did not support Brayboy's claim of automatism, stating he did not believe Brayboy was “on autopilot” when the incident occurred.
The court also highlighted the importance of medical evidence in supporting a claim of automatism. In previous rulings, the court had established that mere self-serving statements from a defendant are insufficient to warrant such an instruction. The court concluded that Brayboy's testimony and the expert's analysis did not meet the legal threshold required for the automatism defense.
This ruling has significant implications for future cases involving claims of automatism. It reinforces the necessity for defendants to present compelling medical evidence to support their claims of acting without conscious control. The decision also clarifies the responsibilities of defendants to preserve their arguments for appeal by raising them during the trial.
Looking ahead, Brayboy's legal options may be limited. The ruling from the Court of Appeals is final unless there are grounds for further appeal to the North Carolina Supreme Court. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any pending related cases or potential appeals. However, this case serves as a critical reference point for defendants seeking to use the automatism defense in North Carolina.
Read Next
Court upholds conviction of Lamont Barrino for firearm possession
Court affirms summary judgment in Bratcher Adams case
Court affirms dismissal of Lozada's appeal in ejectment case
Court vacates ruling on marijuana use for religious practices
Court denies Shah's request to disqualify judge in fraud case
Idaho Court of Appeals upholds drug possession convictions









