The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has upheld the removal of Geoffrey Butlak, a Customs and Border Protection Officer, from his position at the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). The court's decision, issued on November 18, 2026, confirmed that Butlak was removed for lack of candor and conduct unbecoming an officer. This ruling is significant as it reinforces the standards of conduct expected from federal employees, particularly those in law enforcement roles.

Butlak's case arose from an incident on April 26, 2022, when he was late for his shift at the Nashville Global Entry Enrollment Center. He initially informed a fellow officer that he was heading to a different location, the Federal Inspection Station, which led to a series of miscommunications. When he arrived late, he was asked to input leave for his tardiness, which he contested by claiming he had mistakenly reported to the wrong location. However, video evidence showed that he never went to the Federal Inspection Station, leading to charges against him.

The Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) reviewed the case after Butlak was proposed for removal by the agency's Discipline Review Board. The charges against him included lack of candor for allegedly fabricating his reason for being late and conduct unbecoming for asking another officer to lie on his behalf. The MSPB upheld these charges, leading Butlak to appeal the decision to the Federal Circuit.

In its ruling, the court affirmed the MSPB's decision, stating that Butlak did not identify any errors in the Board's findings. The court noted, "We affirm the Board’s decision unless it is arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law." The judges emphasized that Butlak's actions constituted a serious breach of trust and integrity expected from a federal officer.

The court also addressed Butlak's arguments regarding the exclusion of a witness, Mr. Ferguson, who he claimed could have provided testimony to support his case. However, the court sided with the MSPB, stating that Butlak's own stipulation indicated he had attempted to influence Ferguson's testimony. The court ruled that asking someone to relay information is indeed an attempt to influence, and thus, the administrative judge did not abuse his discretion in excluding Ferguson from testifying.

Furthermore, the court found that the removal penalty was reasonable given the circumstances. The administrative judge had considered the potential for Giglio impairment, which refers to issues that could affect the credibility of a law enforcement officer's testimony. Butlak's admission of lying and involving another officer in that lie supported the conclusion that his removal was justified.

This ruling has implications for federal employees, particularly those in law enforcement. It underscores the importance of honesty and integrity in public service roles. The court's decision serves as a reminder that misconduct, especially involving deceit, can lead to severe consequences, including termination.

Looking ahead, Butlak may have limited options for appeal, as the Federal Circuit's ruling is final unless there are grounds for further legal challenges. There are no related cases pending that could directly impact this decision. However, the case may influence future disciplinary actions within federal agencies, as it reinforces the standards of conduct expected from employees.