The Iowa Supreme Court ruled on November 20, 2026, that a will contest filed by beneficiaries of Lorraine Schultz's estate was untimely. The court's decision affects the distribution of Schultz's estate and emphasizes the importance of adhering to statutory deadlines in probate cases.
In this case, three of Schultz's grandchildren challenged the validity of her 2003 will, which significantly altered the distribution of her estate. The court's ruling underscores the need for beneficiaries to act promptly when contesting a will.
Background
The case, titled In the Matter of the Estate of Lorraine Schultz, arose from a dispute over the distribution of Lorraine Schultz's estate following her death on January 11, 2019. Lorraine had executed a new will in 2003 that changed how her farm properties would be divided among her four children: Blaine, Jacquelyn, Annette, and Deborah.
Under the 2003 will, Blaine was set to receive a larger portion of the estate compared to his sisters. After learning about the 2003 will years later, Jacquelyn and Annette, along with Deborah's children, sought to contest its validity, claiming lack of testamentary capacity and undue influence. They argued that a family settlement agreement signed in 2014 should toll the limitations period for contesting the will.
The dispute reached the Iowa Supreme Court after the Iowa Court of Appeals affirmed a lower court's decision to deny the motion to dismiss the will contest. The objectors, Blaine's children, argued that the will contest was filed too late under Iowa law.
The Ruling
The Iowa Supreme Court ruled that the will contest was indeed filed outside the statutory deadline set by Iowa Code § 633.309. Justice McDermott, writing for the court, stated, "The plaintiffs needed to file a timely will contest to preserve their lack-of-capacity and undue-influence claims." The court emphasized that the law does not provide for tolling the statute of limitations based on the existence of a family settlement agreement.
The court noted that the limitations period for contesting a will begins when the will is admitted to probate, which occurred on January 29, 2019. The plaintiffs failed to file their contest until June 2024, well beyond the four-month deadline. The court stated, "We have never held that the existence, filing, or later invalidation of a family settlement agreement tolls or restarts the § 633.309 period for a filed will."
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for future probate cases in Iowa. It reinforces the strict adherence to statutory deadlines for filing will contests, which is crucial for ensuring the orderly settlement of estates. The court's decision clarifies that beneficiaries must act quickly to contest a will, as delays can result in losing the right to challenge a will's validity.
The ruling also highlights the importance of understanding the legal implications of family settlement agreements in probate proceedings. Beneficiaries must be aware that such agreements do not necessarily extend or toll the time limits for filing will contests, as established by Iowa law.
What's Next
The court's decision is final, and there are no further appeals available in this case. The ruling effectively dismisses the will contest filed by Jacquelyn, Annette, and Deborah's children, allowing the estate to be distributed according to the terms of the 2003 will.
Read Next
Iowa Court Affirms Termination of Parental Rights for R.H.
Iowa court affirms guardianship for children amid safety concerns
Iowa Court Affirms Divorce Default Ruling Against Zachary Goken
California Court of Appeal rules on Gonsalves divorce case
California court reverses conservatorship ruling for W.W.
Georgia Court Dismisses Ramsey's Appeal Against Lodge Group










