The Massachusetts Appeals Court recently ruled on a significant case involving the Blackman's Point Homeowners' Association and the Blackman family, who own a manufactured housing community in Marshfield. This case, docket number AC 25-P-1078, addresses the rights of homeowners in a manufactured housing community when the owners of the land seek to discontinue the park and sell the property for a different purpose. The court's decision could impact homeowners' rights across similar communities in Massachusetts.
The court's ruling is critical because it clarifies the legal obligations of landowners under the Manufactured Housing Act and the enforceability of prior settlement agreements. The outcome affects not only the parties involved but also sets a precedent for how manufactured housing communities are treated under Massachusetts law.
Background
The Blackman's Point Homeowners' Association represents the interests of residents in the manufactured housing community, which has been owned and operated by various members of the Blackman family for decades. The park is located on oceanfront land and operates seasonally from May 1 to September 30. The dispute dates back to the 1980s when the Blackmans expressed interest in discontinuing the park or selling the land. A settlement agreement was reached in 1988, requiring the Blackmans to continue operating the park unless they received a bona fide offer to purchase the land.
In March 2020, the homeowners' association and individual tenants filed a lawsuit against the Blackmans, claiming the owners were not adhering to the settlement agreement or the procedures outlined in the Manufactured Housing Act. The plaintiffs argued that the Blackmans could not discontinue the park without offering the homeowners the opportunity to exercise their right of first refusal to purchase the land.
The Ruling
The Massachusetts Appeals Court ruled in favor of the homeowners' association, stating that the Blackmans could not discontinue the park to facilitate the sale of the land. The court emphasized that the Manufactured Housing Act protects tenants from displacement and requires landowners to follow specific procedures when discontinuing a manufactured housing community. The court stated, "The act prohibits the Blackmans from discontinuing the park, having the manufactured homes removed, and then offering the land for sale."
The judges involved in the ruling were Desmond, Tan, and Wood. They found that the 1988 settlement agreement was enforceable and served as an independent prohibition against discontinuing the park. The court also noted that the Blackmans' actions could violate the Consumer Protection Act, which prohibits unfair or deceptive acts.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for manufactured housing communities in Massachusetts. It reinforces the protections afforded to homeowners who own their homes but not the land beneath them. The decision clarifies that landowners must follow the statutory procedures outlined in the Manufactured Housing Act, ensuring that tenants have the opportunity to purchase the land before any discontinuation occurs.
The court's decision also highlights the importance of settlement agreements in maintaining the rights of homeowners. By affirming the enforceability of the 1988 settlement agreement, the court ensures that the Blackmans cannot unilaterally decide to discontinue the park without considering the homeowners' rights. This ruling sets a precedent that could influence future cases involving similar disputes in manufactured housing communities.
What's Next
The case has been remanded for further proceedings, particularly regarding the homeowners' claim for violation of the Consumer Protection Act. The Blackmans may still have the option to appeal the ruling, but the decision currently stands as a strong protection for the homeowners in this community.
Read Next
Massachusetts Court Denies Latham's Petition Against Aramark
Massachusetts Appeals Court rules on public records case
Massachusetts Court Upholds Drug Evidence in Traffic Stop
Court affirms denial of records request in Ng v. Dept. of State
Oregon Court Reverses Trust Judgment Amid Family Dispute
Oregon court upholds $500 contempt sanction in McElroy case










