The Texas Supreme Court recently ruled in a case involving Marquez AD, LLC, a landscaping business, granting mandamus relief related to a contract dispute with Jarrod Adreon. The court decided that a lower court acted beyond its authority when it modified a final judgment regarding attorney’s fees. This ruling is significant as it clarifies the limits of a court's power to change judgments after a certain period.
The case began when Marquez AD, LLC sued Adreon in May 2021 over a contract disagreement. After a jury trial, Marquez won the case in August 2023. Following the trial, Marquez filed a motion for attorney’s fees, claiming it was entitled to nearly $82,000. A week later, during a hearing on the fees, the court indicated it was inclined to award only nominal fees but did not make a final decision at that time.
On November 20, 2023, the court signed Marquez’s proposed final judgment, awarding the full amount of attorney’s fees requested. This judgment was deemed final and appealable, disposing of all claims in the case. However, the case remained inactive for several months until Adreon filed a motion in July 2024 to reform the judgment, claiming it was erroneous. In September 2024, the court held a hearing and subsequently issued an order that reduced Marquez’s attorney’s fees to approximately $2,000, requiring Marquez to return the funds received under the original judgment.
Marquez then sought mandamus relief from the Texas Supreme Court, arguing that the district court’s modification of the final judgment was void because the court had lost its authority to change it after a specified time. The court of appeals had previously denied Marquez’s request for relief, prompting the case to reach the Texas Supreme Court under docket number 25-0175.
The Texas Supreme Court ruled unanimously that the district court had indeed acted beyond its authority. The court stated, "Attempting to set aside a final judgment after plenary power has expired is a serious jurisdictional overstep for which a writ of mandamus is an appropriate remedy." The court emphasized that the district court’s power to modify its final judgment expired 30 days after the judgment was signed, which was in December 2023, well before the September 2024 order was issued.
The court further clarified that while the district court may have expressed an inclination to award nominal fees during a previous hearing, this did not constitute a firm decision. The signed judgment from November 2023 was the only clear indication of the court's decision regarding attorney’s fees. The court noted that any modifications made after the expiration of plenary power were invalid.
As a result of the ruling, the Texas Supreme Court conditionally granted mandamus relief, directing the district court to vacate its September 2024 order and reinstate the November 2023 judgment. The court expressed confidence that the lower court would comply with this directive.
This ruling has important implications for future cases involving modifications of final judgments in Texas. It reinforces the principle that courts have a limited time frame to alter their decisions and that any attempts to do so after this period may be deemed invalid. This decision may serve as a precedent for similar cases where the authority of a court to modify judgments is called into question.
Moving forward, the parties involved in this case may explore further legal options, including the possibility of an appeal by Adreon, although details regarding any potential appeal were not specified in the court filing. Additionally, the court's opinion cautioned that the ruling addresses only this case and does not alter the law regarding judgments nunc pro tunc, which are used to correct clerical errors.
Read Next
Texas Supreme Court dismisses abortion case as moot
Texas court dismisses appeal for failure to pay fees
Texas Appeals Court Reverses Estate Ruling on Conversion Damages
Kansas Court Rules on Zoning Dispute Over Hunting Facility
Kansas Court Addresses AI Misuse in Legal Filings
Florida Court Affirms Ruling in Fulton v. State of Florida










