The Texas Supreme Court recently ruled in the case of Santander Consumer USA Inc. v. Enterprise Financial Group, Inc., reversing a lower court's decision regarding jury charge objections. This ruling allows Santander to challenge the jury's decision in a breach of contract dispute that has significant implications for both companies involved.
This case centers around a contractual disagreement between Santander Consumer USA Inc., a company that provides auto loans, and Enterprise Financial Group, Inc., which sells consumer protection products. The dispute arose from a Vendor Services Agreement entered into by both companies in 2012, allowing Santander to market and sell Enterprise's guaranteed asset protection (GAP) policies. However, the arrangement did not meet expectations, leading Enterprise to terminate the agreement in 2017 and subsequently sue Santander for breach of contract.
During the trial, a jury found that both parties breached the agreement, with Enterprise being awarded $5 million in damages. Santander, however, argued that the jury charge, which guided the jury on how to deliberate, contained errors that affected the outcome of the trial. Specifically, Santander claimed that the jury charge did not properly define the types of damages that could be awarded and that it allowed for the possibility of awarding lost profits without sufficient evidence.
After Santander's appeal was denied by the court of appeals, the case made its way to the Texas Supreme Court. The key issue was whether Santander had preserved its objections to the jury charge, which the lower court had previously ruled were not preserved. The Texas Supreme Court disagreed with the lower court's assessment.
The court ruled that Santander had indeed preserved its objections regarding the jury charge. In its opinion, the court stated, "A party objecting to a charge must point out distinctly the objectionable matter and the grounds of the objection." This indicates that Santander had made timely and specific objections during the trial, which should allow them to contest the jury's findings.
The Texas Supreme Court's ruling emphasized the importance of the jury charge in guiding the jury's decision-making process. The court noted that the charge did not specify which types of damages the jury should consider and allowed for the possibility of awarding lost profits, which Santander argued were not supported by the evidence presented at trial. The court stated, "Question 8B asked the jury to decide what damages, if any, Enterprise suffered because of any breach of contract by Santander. The charge did not identify what measures of damages the jury should consider or provide separate blanks for direct or consequential damages."
As a result of this ruling, the Texas Supreme Court reversed the lower court's judgment and remanded the case back to the court of appeals for further consideration. The court of appeals will now need to evaluate whether the jury charge was erroneous and, if so, whether that error caused harm to Santander's case.
The impact of this ruling extends beyond the immediate case. It reinforces the principle that parties in a trial must clearly articulate their objections to jury charges to preserve their rights for appeal. This ruling could influence future cases involving jury charges and the preservation of objections, as it highlights the need for clarity and specificity in trial proceedings.
Looking ahead, the case will return to the court of appeals, where the judges will review the jury charge and determine if the objections raised by Santander were valid. If the court finds that the charge was indeed erroneous and that the error was harmful, it could lead to a new trial. This case serves as a reminder of the complexities involved in legal disputes and the critical role that jury instructions play in the judicial process.
In conclusion, the Texas Supreme Court's decision in Santander Consumer USA Inc. v. Enterprise Financial Group, Inc. not only affects the parties involved but also sets a precedent for how jury charge objections are handled in the future. As the case moves forward, it will be essential to monitor the court of appeals' decisions and any potential implications for similar cases.
Read Next
Texas Supreme Court rules on school district contract dispute
Texas Supreme Court dismisses abortion case as moot
Texas Court dismisses appeal over jurisdiction issues
Court upholds pension forfeiture for former state employee
Kentucky Court Affirms Ruling in Property Dispute Case
Alabama court terminates parental rights in custody case










