The Nebraska Supreme Court ruled on November 20, 2026, that the appointment of a special prosecutor in a criminal case was unjustified due to a lack of evidence. This decision affects the Sarpy County Attorney's office and clarifies the standards for appointing special prosecutors in Nebraska.
The case arose from a criminal complaint against Delmar Alexander Rodriguez Morales, who faced charges of first-degree sexual assault of a child under 12 years of age. The Sarpy County Attorney's office was initially involved in the prosecution, with Deputy County Attorney Peter Pirsch assigned to the case. However, after defense counsel raised concerns about alleged ex parte communications between Pirsch and the county court judge, the district court appointed a special prosecutor from the Attorney General's office, Demetria Herman, to replace the Sarpy County Attorney's office.
The dispute escalated when the Sarpy County Attorney's office challenged the appointment of the special prosecutor, arguing that there was no evidence of a conflict of interest or misconduct. The district court's decision to appoint a special prosecutor was based on the appearance of impropriety rather than concrete evidence, which led to the Attorney General's office filing a quo warranto action to contest Herman's authority as special prosecutor.
The Nebraska Supreme Court examined the circumstances surrounding the appointment of the special prosecutor. The court noted that the district court's ruling on such appointments is typically discretionary. However, it emphasized that a motion for a special prosecutor must be supported by evidence of a conflict of interest or other valid reasons as outlined in Nebraska Revised Statute § 23-1205.
The court stated, "We hold that the district court abused its discretion by appointing a special prosecutor pursuant to § 23-1205, over the Sarpy County Attorney office’s objection, when there was no evidence presented at all, let alone that supported a disqualifying conflict of interest." This ruling underscores the necessity for concrete evidence when alleging conflicts of interest in prosecutorial roles.
The court also highlighted that the mere appearance of impropriety is insufficient to warrant the disqualification of an entire prosecutorial office. The ruling clarified that a conflict of interest must be based on reliable evidence rather than speculation or unsworn statements from counsel. The court noted that defense counsel had not raised the issue of ex parte communications during the preliminary hearing and only brought it up after the case had been bound over to the district court.
The implications of this ruling are significant for the Sarpy County Attorney's office and other prosecutorial entities in Nebraska. The court's decision reinforces the importance of maintaining the integrity of the prosecutorial process while ensuring that allegations of misconduct are substantiated with evidence. The ruling serves as a reminder that the legal framework governing the appointment of special prosecutors is designed to protect the rights of defendants while upholding the responsibilities of prosecuting attorneys.
Moving forward, the Nebraska Supreme Court's ruling may influence how future cases involving allegations of prosecutorial misconduct are handled. Prosecutors may be more cautious in their interactions with judges and defense counsel to avoid potential conflicts of interest. Additionally, defense attorneys may need to provide more substantial evidence when raising concerns about prosecutorial conduct to ensure their claims are taken seriously.
As for next steps, it remains to be seen whether the Sarpy County Attorney's office will pursue further action in this case or if any related cases will emerge as a result of this ruling. The court's decision does not prevent future challenges regarding prosecutorial conduct, but it does establish a higher threshold for evidence in such matters.
Read Next
Court rules in favor of Metropolitan Utilities in discrimination case
Nebraska Court upholds convictions for domestic assault case
Nebraska court affirms convictions in child exploitation case
Ohio court rules on appeal of aggravated murder conviction
Ohio court affirms felony murder conviction in shooting case
Ohio Court affirms denial of Dewayne Kinder's appeals










