A Florida court has ruled in favor of a bar in a personal injury case involving a patron who claimed she was served alcohol despite being habitually addicted. The ruling, made by the District Court of Appeal of Florida on November 18, 2026, affects how bars and other establishments can be held liable under Florida's dram shop statute.

The case, Samantha L. Croteau v. Bella Construction of Key West, Inc., Docket No. 4D2025-1536, centers around Samantha Croteau, who alleged that Family 5, Inc., doing business as Whistle Stop, served her alcoholic beverages knowing she was addicted to alcohol. Croteau was injured later that night after consuming alcohol at the bar.

The court's decision is significant as it highlights the limitations of liability for bars when it comes to serving alcohol to patrons. The ruling clarifies that bars are not liable for injuries resulting from intoxication unless they knowingly serve someone who is habitually addicted to alcohol.

Background

Samantha Croteau was a patron at the Whistle Stop bar on March 10 and 11, 2021. She claimed that the bar served her alcohol despite her being habitually addicted to alcohol, which she argued led to her injuries later that night. Croteau was struck by a vehicle while attempting to cross a highway after experiencing a flat tire, with her blood alcohol level recorded at .234, nearly three times the legal limit.

The bar, represented by attorneys from GrayRobinson, P.A., denied the allegations and filed a motion for summary judgment, asserting that there was no evidence they knew Croteau was addicted to alcohol. The bar argued that Croteau was an anonymous patron who did not exhibit any signs of intoxication or addiction during her visit.

The circuit court granted the bar's motion for summary judgment, leading Croteau to appeal the decision. The court found that there was no genuine issue of material fact regarding the bar's knowledge of Croteau's alleged addiction.

The Ruling

The District Court of Appeal upheld the lower court's decision, affirming the summary judgment in favor of the bar. The court ruled that there was no evidence to support Croteau's claim that the bar knowingly served her alcohol despite her addiction. The court stated, "The bar did not know the plaintiff was 'habitually addicted to the use of any or all alcoholic beverages.'"

The court emphasized that Croteau's behavior during her visit was unremarkable, noting her own testimony that she did not interact with the bartender or exhibit any signs of intoxication. The court referenced the Florida dram shop statute, which protects alcohol vendors from liability unless they knowingly serve someone who is a habitual alcoholic.

The ruling also pointed to previous cases, including Ellis v. N.G.N. of Tampa, Inc., which established that serving an individual multiple drinks on one occasion does not, by itself, prove that a vendor knowingly served a habitual drunkard. The court concluded that the evidence presented did not meet the statutory criteria for establishing liability.

Impact

This ruling has important implications for bars and other establishments serving alcohol in Florida. It reinforces the protections offered to alcohol vendors under the dram shop statute, which limits their liability in cases involving patrons who later suffer injuries due to intoxication. The court's decision clarifies that vendors must have actual knowledge of a patron's habitual addiction to alcohol to be held liable for any resulting injuries.

The ruling may also discourage similar claims against bars, as it sets a precedent that emphasizes the necessity of proving a vendor's knowledge of a patron's addiction. This decision could lead to fewer successful lawsuits against bars in cases involving alcohol-related injuries, as plaintiffs will need to provide more substantial evidence to establish liability.

What's Next

Croteau's legal options appear limited following this ruling, as the court affirmed the summary judgment. It is unclear whether she will seek further appeals. There are no related cases pending that were mentioned in the court filing. The decision serves as a reminder of the complexities involved in personal injury cases related to alcohol consumption and the legal protections available to alcohol vendors.