The North Carolina Court of Appeals has upheld the dismissal of a medical malpractice case involving Karen Singleton against Dr. David Clinton McNabb and Raleigh Orthopaedic Clinic. The court's decision, made on November 18, 2026, stems from Singleton's repeated failures to comply with discovery orders, which ultimately led to the dismissal of her claims with prejudice.
This ruling is significant as it reinforces the importance of adhering to court orders during litigation. It serves as a reminder to plaintiffs that non-compliance with discovery requirements can have severe consequences, including the dismissal of their case.
Background
The case, Singleton v. McNabb, began when Karen Singleton filed a complaint against Dr. McNabb and his clinic on February 14, 2020. Singleton alleged that Dr. McNabb failed to perform adequate measurements of her leg before conducting a total hip replacement surgery. She claimed that this negligence resulted in her leg being improperly lengthened, causing severe pain, loss of feeling, and the need for extensive physical therapy.
Singleton's complaint was met with a denial from the defendants, who asserted that they were not liable for her injuries. The case has a lengthy procedural history, with Singleton appealing several trial court decisions, including orders related to discovery violations and sanctions imposed against her for failing to provide requested medical records.
The trial court had previously imposed sanctions on Singleton for not complying with discovery orders, including an order that required her to produce medical records and journals documenting her condition. Singleton's failure to comply with these orders led to further motions from the defendants seeking dismissal of her claims.
The Ruling
The Court of Appeals, led by Judge Christopher Freeman, ruled on Singleton's appeal following the trial court's orders dismissing her complaint with prejudice and denying her motion to amend her complaint. The court affirmed the lower court's decisions, stating, "The trial court did not err by dismissing the action and by denying plaintiff’s motion for leave to amend."
In its opinion, the court noted that Singleton had repeatedly failed to produce her journals and other discovery materials as ordered by the court. The judges emphasized that the trial court had considered lesser sanctions before opting for dismissal, which is a significant factor in upholding such a severe decision.
Impact
This ruling has important implications for future cases involving discovery violations. It underscores the necessity for plaintiffs to comply with court orders and the potential repercussions for failing to do so. The court's decision reinforces the idea that the legal system requires cooperation and transparency from all parties involved in litigation.
Furthermore, the ruling may serve as a cautionary tale for other plaintiffs who may consider withholding evidence or failing to comply with discovery requests. The court's affirmation of the dismissal suggests that similar cases could face the same fate if parties do not adhere to procedural rules.
What's Next
Singleton may have the option to appeal the decision to the North Carolina Supreme Court, but details regarding any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. As of now, there are no related cases pending that would affect this ruling.
Read Next
Court upholds conviction of Lamont Barrino for firearm possession
Court affirms dismissal of Lozada's appeal in ejectment case
North Carolina court affirms termination of father's rights
Florida court rules on damages in auto accident case
Court affirms bar's immunity in alcohol-related injury case
Court rules against statute limiting medical negligence claims










