The Florida District Court of Appeal has upheld a jury verdict favoring landlords Stephen and Traci Lister in a premises liability case. The court ruled on November 18, 2026, in the case of George McCarty v. Stephen Lister and Traci Lister, docket number 4D2025-1761. This decision is significant as it impacts how similar cases may be handled in the future, particularly regarding the admissibility of certain evidence and the conduct of attorneys during trials.
The McCarty family, which includes George, Carrie, Kelcee, and Jessica McCarty, along with George McCarty acting as the parent and guardian of minor T.M., appealed the final judgment after a jury sided with their landlords. The family argued that the landlords' attorney made improper references to McCarty's consultation with an attorney, which they believed warranted a mistrial or a new trial. They also claimed that the trial court did not adequately instruct the jury on the landlords' maintenance duties.
This case arose after George McCarty suffered serious injuries from a fall over a seawall at the home rented from the Listers. McCarty testified that the ground beside the seawall had opened beneath him, causing him to fall. He and his family attributed the accident to defective seawall construction and erosion. However, the Listers disputed this account, citing inconsistencies in McCarty's medical records regarding how the accident occurred.
The dispute escalated to a jury trial, where the McCartys contended that the landlords were liable for their injuries due to negligence in maintaining the property. The Listers' defense relied on McCarty's medical records, which contained varying descriptions of the incident, including claims that he had slipped while fishing. The Listers argued that these discrepancies were significant and undermined McCarty's credibility.
During the trial, the landlords' attorney made comments suggesting that McCarty had altered his story after consulting an attorney. The McCartys objected to these statements, and the trial court sustained their objections, instructing the jury to disregard the comments. Despite this, the McCartys sought a mistrial, claiming that the comments were prejudicial and could not be remedied by the court's instructions.
The court ultimately ruled against the McCartys, affirming the jury's verdict for the Listers. The court noted that while the comments made by the landlords' counsel were improper, they did not rise to the level of prejudice that would warrant a new trial. The court stated, "The improper comments, considered in conjunction with the trial court’s adequate response thereto, were not so highly inflammatory and prejudicial as to deny the McCartys the right to a fair trial." This ruling was made by Judge Ciklin, with Judges Lott and Carbuccia concurring.
The impact of this ruling is significant for future premises liability cases in Florida. It reinforces the importance of how attorneys conduct themselves during trials and the necessity for trial courts to provide clear instructions to juries. The court's decision also highlights the balance between ensuring a fair trial and addressing improper conduct by legal counsel.
Going forward, this ruling may influence how similar cases are approached, especially concerning the admissibility of evidence and the conduct of attorneys. It emphasizes that while improper comments can occur, they do not automatically lead to a mistrial if the trial court takes appropriate corrective action.
As for what’s next, the McCarty family has the option to file a motion for rehearing, as the court's decision is not final until such a motion is resolved. There are no indications in the court filing of any related cases pending.
Read Next
Court reverses dismissal of privacy complaint against 5 Star Nutrition
Florida Court Affirms Eviction Judgment Against Tenant
Florida court affirms decision in Kelsey v. State of Florida
North Carolina court upholds dismissal in medical malpractice case
Court affirms bar's immunity in alcohol-related injury case
Court rules against statute limiting medical negligence claims










