A New York appellate court has reversed a previous ruling concerning a dispute over attorney fees between the law firm Abrams Fensterman, LLP, and clients Maria and Amy Sausa. The court's decision, issued on November 18, 2026, in the case Matter of Abrams Fensterman, LLP v. Sausa (docket number 2024-11162), mandates a hearing to resolve the amount of a charging lien claimed by the law firm against a settlement reached by the Sausas.
This ruling affects the Sausas, who are now required to address the attorney fees they owe, and it underscores the importance of clarity in attorney-client financial agreements. The case highlights the legal complexities surrounding charging liens and the necessity for attorneys to provide reasonable and transparent billing practices.
Background
The dispute began when the Sausas retained Abrams Fensterman, LLP, to represent them in two legal actions related to a construction project. The Sausas hired the law firm in 2018 to help them recover damages from contractors and architects involved in the project. They paid an initial retainer of $25,000 and agreed to hourly rates of $525 for attorney Amy Marion and $450 for other attorneys.
However, in 2022, the Sausas stopped making payments after they noticed that Marion had increased her hourly rate without notifying them. By 2023, the rate had risen to $750, which the Sausas disputed. After the Sausas settled their claims against the architects for $300,000 in September 2023, Abrams Fensterman sought to enforce a charging lien on the settlement proceeds for the unpaid legal fees.
The Ruling
The appellate court ruled that the lower court had made an error by granting the charging lien without holding a hearing. The court stated, "questions of fact exist as to which invoices, if any, the Sausas can be deemed to have assented to." The judges emphasized that the law firm had not sufficiently demonstrated the reasonableness of its fees, which is crucial in determining the validity of the lien.
Judges Angela G. Iannacci, Paul Wooten, Laurence L. Love, and Elena Goldberg Velazquez concurred in this decision. The court's ruling sends the case back to the Supreme Court of Nassau County for a hearing to reassess the petition regarding the charging lien and to determine the appropriate amount owed.
Impact
This ruling is significant as it highlights the legal standards that must be met when enforcing a charging lien. It emphasizes the necessity for attorneys to prove the reasonableness of their fees, particularly when clients dispute the charges. The case serves as a reminder to clients to closely monitor their legal bills and to communicate any concerns promptly.
Going forward, this decision may influence how attorneys bill their clients, particularly in cases where fees are contested. It underscores the importance of clear communication and agreement between attorneys and clients regarding billing practices. The outcome of the upcoming hearing will determine the final amount the Sausas owe, which could set a precedent for similar cases involving attorney fees and charging liens.
What's Next
The matter is now remitted to the Supreme Court of Nassau County for a hearing to determine the amount of the charging lien. The Sausas and Abrams Fensterman will have the opportunity to present their cases regarding the disputed fees. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any potential appeals or related cases pending.
Read Next
New York court upholds child maltreatment report against father
New York court grants father sole custody in family dispute
New York court dismisses appeal in parental rights case
Texas Court dismisses whistleblower claims against DISD
Texas Court Rules on Discovery in Chemical Company Case
Court rules on foreclosure irregularity in Zalewski case










