A New York court has issued a ruling on a significant estate administration case involving a disputed real estate contract. The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York decided on November 18, 2026, in the case of Matter of Bartiromo (Docket No. 2025-13693). This ruling affects the parties involved in the estate of the deceased Patsy Bartiromo, specifically the petitioners Aaron Schneck and Chaya Gitty Schneck, and the estate's administrator, Ivana Bartiromo.

The dispute centers around a contract for the sale of real property that the petitioners claim is enforceable. The court's decision is crucial as it clarifies the legal standing of the contract and the rights of the parties involved in the estate administration process.

The background of this case involves Aaron Schneck and Chaya Gitty Schneck, who allege they entered into a contract to purchase real property from Patsy Bartiromo in July 2018. They made a down payment to the decedent's attorney. However, the closing on the contract did not occur before Bartiromo's death on September 8, 2021. Following her death, Ivana Bartiromo commenced a proceeding for the administration of the estate in February 2022. The Surrogate's Court appointed her as the administrator in November 2022.

The petitioners filed a second amended petition seeking a judgment to declare the contract enforceable and to authorize the conveyance of the property under the Surrogate's Court Procedure Act (SCPA) 1921. In response, Ivana Bartiromo filed an answer with various affirmative defenses and moved to dismiss the petition. The petitioners then cross-moved for summary judgment, seeking to have the court declare the contract enforceable and dismiss the administrator's affirmative defenses.

On September 22, 2025, the Surrogate's Court denied several branches of the petitioners' cross-motion, prompting the appeal. The Appellate Division reviewed the case and ultimately modified the lower court's order. The court ruled that the Surrogate's Court should have granted summary judgment dismissing certain affirmative defenses raised by Ivana Bartiromo.

The court's ruling highlighted that the petitioners had established their entitlement to judgment regarding the sixth, eighth, ninth, tenth, and eleventh affirmative defenses. Specifically, the court stated, "The petitioners established their prima facie entitlement to judgment as a matter of law dismissing the administrator's eighth affirmative defense, alleging that the contract was abandoned, by demonstrating that neither the petitioners nor the decedent engaged in conduct that was entirely at odds with the contract." Additionally, the court noted that the administrator failed to raise a triable issue of fact in opposition to the petitioners' claims.

Judges Mark C. Dillon, Helen Voutsinas, Laurence L. Love, and Elena Goldberg Velazquez concurred in the decision. The ruling clarified the legal standing of the contract and the rights of the petitioners to pursue their claims against the estate of Patsy Bartiromo.

The impact of this ruling is significant for the parties involved in the estate administration process. It establishes that the petitioners have a stronger legal basis to enforce the contract and pursue the conveyance of the property. The decision also sets a precedent for similar cases involving estate administration and contract enforcement, emphasizing the importance of demonstrating a prima facie case in summary judgment motions.

Going forward, this ruling may influence how estate administrators and potential buyers approach real estate contracts in the context of estate proceedings. It underscores the necessity for parties to clearly establish their claims and defenses in such disputes.

As for what’s next, the possibility of an appeal remains. The court did not specify whether the decision could be further contested. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any related cases pending that might impact this ruling.